
Allen Tucker, Peter A. Juley & Son Collection, Smithsonian American Art Museum J0024455. Lisa N. Peters At the outset of our work on a show of the art of Allen Tucker, opening February 25, we gathered what we knew to be the standard reference material on Tucker, but we soon discovered that what we found initially was the tip of the iceberg. More and more articles on Tucker and information on him and his art kept surfacing. As we examined it, we pieced together a full picture of Tucker’s career in the show's catalogue (the most comprehensive yet), realizing in the process that he was an artist of much prominence in New York from the mid-1910s through the 1930s and that he elicited an inordinate amount of respect from his peers for his integrity and broad-mindedness as well as for the creative versatility of his art, which critic Virgil Barker commended in 1928 for its “robust plentitude.” Allen Tucker, "Mountain Landscape, ca. 1911-16
Tucker began his career as an architect, but was led away from this profession by his passion for painting. His early mentor was John Twachtman, with whom he studied at the Art Students League and in Cos Cob, Connecticut. Tucker shared Twachtman’s gentlemanly outlook and genuine appreciation of artistic individuality. After the Armory Show of 1913, in which he played a role in the organization, Tucker was a leading figure in the emergence of the modernist art scene in New York. His work was shown at Montross Gallery, one of the first galleries to respond to the innovations of the Armory Show, and he was an unpaid advisor to Juliana Force, the curator of the Whitney Studio Club, the precursor to the Whitney Museum of American Art. When a memorial show of Tucker’s work was held at the Whitney in 1939, Force recalled Tucker as a man “whose faultless taste in art and inexhaustible sympathy with the problems of his fellow artists led to an association of many years, wherein his wisdom and understanding were of the greatest value in the development of those ideas which resulted in the formation of this museum.”
Tucker was described similarly by his champion, Forbes Watson, art critic for the New York Evening Post and the New York World. Writing several articles and a book on Tucker, Watson was unfailing in his support of Tucker as an artist who fearlessly sought just the right means to express his personal and emotional responses to his subjects. This is borne out in both the diversity of Tucker’s subject matter and his willingness to change his stylistic handling from one work to the next. His admiration for the art of van Gogh, which led to his reputation as “the Vincent of America,” can be seen both in the rhythmic directness of his brushwork and in the way that his feelings drove his expression.
In Mountain Landscape Tucker chose an elevated viewpoint and treated the mountain before us as an upright plane, forgoing foreshortening and using dabs and swirls of color to focus on the energy of light and color across the surface. In Woman in a Garden, the elongated figure in a black coat and high feathered hat is less a part of her space than balanced against it, the spinning clouds perhaps personifying the intensity of her thoughts. A post impressionist who sought his own way, Allen Tucker is overdue a rediscovery for the unceasing vitality of his art and for a determination of his place in the story of the art of his time.












